Monday, 22 September 2008

I, Paulson

GoldEnron Sachs and Morgan Stanley applied to become bank holding companies regulated by the Fed at the weekend, giving them access to wider sources of funding including direct loans. William Isaac, former chairman of the FDIC said, "The decision marks the end of Wall Street as we have known.  It's really too bad, as our country has benefited greatly from the entrepreneurial risk takers on Wall Street." ... interesting perspective ... wonder what planet he's been on this last six months? There's no doubt some people did very well indeed out of Wall Street's "risk taking" ... not sure it's been the country as a whole though.  

Paulson's master plan is now taking shape and looks as though it will involve a request for around $700bn to buy "troubled assets" (not just mortgages) from any bank with US operations (not just US banks). Interesting, Paulson gets unparalleled dictatorial powers to decide what assets to buy and from whom with no provision for subsequent judicial review ... wow ... but add to that the $85bn bail out of AIG and the estimated eventual cost of bailing out the GSEs of $250bn. Then add in the $500bn writedowns already taken by the private sector, and we get to a cost of the crisis so far of about $1.5tr ... as well as a new financial dictator ...  

Greenspan used to say a problem delayed is a problem solved. The Paulson plan will mark the end of this financial crisis by drawing a line under the root cause of the problem - bad system-wide collateral. There is still a recession to come. There is still the possibility that China's real estate bust might make the banking bust we've just seen in the West look like a picnic. And there remains a looming energy crisis.

But there has also been a very sharp increase in US government debt, by around $5-6tr depending on how you measure it. That will take total US govt. debt to around 100% of GDP, not including the "off-balance sheet" committments on health and social security which would likely take it to around a staggering 600% of GDP. Guess who said this:

"The budget should be balanced, public debt should be reduced, the treasury should be rebuilt, the arrogance of officialdom should be tempered and controlled, and assistance to foreign hands should be curtailed."

That's right - Cicero, the famed Roman consul and orator. 

The long-term over-committment of resorces won't trigger the sort of sudden financial crisis we've just been through. It will be a much slower moving decline, like the one currently killing the Detroit auto industry. Although Marcus Tillio Cicero's comment was attributed to around 44AD, for example, the inflation didn't really kick in in the Roman empire until the time of Marcus Aurelius over one hundred years later. Moreover, the Western Roman Empire's power didn't really peak for another hundred years after him, even though history books quote its ultimate demise as happening in 472 (although even this is probably a meaninless date because the real Roman Empire simply moved east to Constantinople and lasted through medieval times only coming to a definitive end when it was sacked by the Turks in 1453) .

The point is that while such massive debt issuance ultimately pressures the integrity of the empire and its currency it is something else to worry about in the future. Right now, the crisis is over. The Japanese, for example, went through a similar episode in the early 1990s and saw their debt load increase significantly as they tried and failed to fiscally revive their economy without fixing their banks. The economic pressures since have been deflationary, not inflationary ... so far ...  

Nevertheless, and regardless of the ultimate time horizon, the process is very clearly underway today. We are seeing a peaking of US imperial influence and historically such peaks have historically been disastrous for the imperial currency ...  gold and silver will serve role as the store of value as they have historically always done in such times. 

Thursday, 18 September 2008

HBOS no more ... Goldenron Sachs? ... will this be another Great Depression? ... let the printing press roll ... gold spikes ... infrastructure bill

Plenty of blood on the streets now ... another ugly close in the US last night (S&P down 4.7%, Nasdaq down 5%) has driven an equally horid session in Asia where markets are down 5-6% as I write. Morgan Stanley came under attack yesterday, its shares falling as far as 44% at one point, before closing around 20% lower. The criticism following the Bear rescue, and then that of the GSEs clearly hurt the US authorities and allowing LEH to go to the wall, and helping out AIG only on stringent and distressed terms was a very deliberate attempt to draw a line under the moral hazard problem. Unfortunately, it now appears as though the whole structure is build on moral hazard. It feels like we just had the rug pulled from under the financial industry ... 

... of course, the authorities presumably knew this would happen and the situation may yet stabilise without any intervention. They will feel they've done a good thing and they'll be right. But we don't know yet if this gamble will pay off. The reality is the wholesale credit markets are closed and there is no liquidity. Without that the entire financial sector, and eventually the real economy, is paralysed. 

Of the five bulge bracket firms last year only two are left, but how long will Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs last? This morning the talk is of Wachovia hooking up with Morgan Stanley, along the lines of BoA and Merrill ... the structural problem built into the broker-dealer model is that these guys rely on wholesale markets for the funding of long-term assets and those markets have dried up. There is a basic flaw in the model which is being painfully exposed. 

Might it be even worse than that though? Stansberry and Associates wrote a few months ago that over the last three years, Goldman Sachs reported net income totaling $19.6 billion but produced a cash flow of negative $93.6 billion - a $113.2 billion disparity. Even when factoring in the returns from its investments (which produce negative operation cash flow), they end up with a net negative number of –$800 million. They concluded "I've got no doubt that Goldman has the world's smartest accountants. In fact, I wonder how many of them used to work at Enron ... "

Back home it looks as though Lloyds have agreed to take out HBOS for 2.32 with regulatory competition restrictions waived. Once in a lifetime market share opportunity for Lloyds, but can't see anything yet on ring fencing HBOS's toxic "assets."

Russia suspended trading on its exchanges for a second day yesterday as the ruble denominated Micex fell by 10% in less than an hour, despite the CB injecting $20bn into the money marketsand the Finance ministry offering $44bn to fund the country's three top banks. KIT Finance, a brokerage, went the way of the Lehman and banks are now no longer lending to one another.  What a familiar sounding mess. 

This is serious on a number of levels though. It has become common to benchmark current situation against the 1930s depression. Everything is the worst, the toughest, the most serious  ... fill in the blank ... since the 1930s. And its true that there were many similarities between what's happened now and what happened then - the availability of cheap credit, the dangerous dependence on that credit to fund the purchase of consumer goods, stocks and fixed investment ... but there are many differences too. 

Firstly, the policy response was different. The Fed believed that allowing bankrupties was the right economically and even morally as it had been warning on the dangers of reckless lending in the preceding years. As the banking system was engulfed in panic and the money supply contracted by one third the Fed sat idly by. Milton Friedman believed that this alone was the difference between what should have been an ordinary recession and the depression which ensued. The rest of the US government was similarly inactive, failing to respond with any sort of fiscal stimulus until Roosevelt's new deal in 1933. Indeed, in the meantime, the government enacted the Smoot-Hawley Act which put up trade barriers and set off a chain reaction of similar responses around the world causing a collapse in world trade. 

Compare that to the central bank liquidity provision, the monetary and the fiscal stimulus we've already seen so far and the current downturn shouldn't be anywhere near what was seen in the 30s. There is no legislating for the utter stupidity of politicians of course, and there are increasingly autarkic noises emanating from the US (autarky as a policy of economic independence and non-trade was born in the 1930s incidentally) but with such a strong trading ethos throughout Europe and Asia it is difficult to imagine the world lurching back into the isolationism of the early 1930s.   

But there is one more aspect to the 1930s crash which is less widely discussed - the US was then the world's biggest creditor nation. When its domestic economy hit the skids it pulled that foreign capital home, badly destabilising the countries it had invested in (most notably Weimar Germany). This time round we have seen the opposite. The creditor nations of the world in Asia and the Middle East have stepped up their investment in the US and played a pivotal role in the recapitalisation of the financial system.

Russia hasn't been a big player in that respect, but neither is Russia the only EM to be in meltdown. The Chinese stock mkt is now down 60% from its peak and its real estate market is looking dangerous indeed with home prices as much as 25% lower in major cities and annecdotal evidence of white elephants all over the country. In other words, the collateral backing of China's banks' balance sheets may not be as robust as it appeared during the upturn. Any fix will likely include their massive foreign reserves which would require a repatriation of the capital currently invested in the US. You could come to a similar conclusion looking at the Gulf states, where authorities appear to be trying their best to prop up domestic share markets while the suddenly softer oil price is reducing inflows of dollars by the day ...

Yesterday the US treasury announced it would give the Fed another $100bn to restore its balance sheet following the AIG loan. Where does the Fed get the money for all those treasuries? The printing press. The ultimate solution to this mess will be the monetisation of dodgy collateral, which may or may not lead to another sort of mess further down the line. Interestingly, gold started its staggering 10% intraday rise almost immediately following that announcement breaking its hitherto tight correlation with the dollar. The dollar this morning though, is weak ...

A study by National Bank Financial says an oil sands mine, including upgrader needs a price of $85 to be economic. Meanwhile, the financial bust is going to make it harder for firms to raise the $179bn the industry expects to need for investment over the next ten years. That's worth bearing in mind as commodity prices sink. The EIA estimated that in the next 25 years the world would need to invest $30tr to satisfy its energy needs. Estimates of the required infrastructure in clean water provision over the same period take that number up to $40tr, or $1.6tr per year. That's more than the annual run rate of the current global financial crisis, for twenty five years ... 

Wednesday, 17 September 2008

Will this be another great depression? ... let the printing presses roll

Plenty of blood on the streets now ... another ugly close in the US last night (S&P down 4.7%, Nasdaq down 5%) has driven an equally horid session in Asia where markets are down 5-6% as I write. Morgan Stanley came under attack yesterday, its shares falling as far as 44% at one point, before closing around 20% lower. The criticism following the Bear rescue, and then that of the GSEs clearly hurt the US authorities and allowing LEH to go to the wall, and helping out AIG only on stringent and distressed terms was a very deliberate attempt to draw a line under the moral hazard problem. Unfortunately, it now appears as though the whole structure is build on moral hazard. It feels like we just had the rug pulled from under the financial industry ... 

... of course, the authorities presumably knew this would happen and the situation may yet stabilise without any intervention. They will feel they've done a good thing and they'll be right. But we don't know yet if this gamble will pay off. The reality is the wholesale credit markets are closed and there is no liquidity. Without that the entire financial sector, and eventually the real economy, is paralysed. 

Of the five bulge bracket firms last year only two are left, but how long will Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs last? This morning the talk is of Wachovia hooking up with Morgan Stanley, along the lines of BoA and Merrill ... the structural problem built into the broker-dealer model is that these guys rely on wholesale markets for the funding of long-term assets and those markets have dried up. There is a basic flaw in the model which is being painfully exposed. 

Might it be even worse than that though? Stansberry and Associates wrote a few months ago that over the last three years, Goldman Sachs reported net income totaling $19.6 billion but produced a cash flow of negative $93.6 billion - a $113.2 billion disparity. Even when factoring in the returns from its investments (which produce negative operation cash flow), they end up with a net negative number of –$800 million. They concluded "I've got no doubt that Goldman has the world's smartest accountants. In fact, I wonder how many of them used to work at Enron ... "

Back home it looks as though Lloyds have agreed to take out HBOS for 2.32 with regulatory competition restrictions waived. Once in a lifetime market share opportunity for Lloyds, but can't see anything yet on ring fencing HBOS's toxic "assets."

Russia suspended trading on its exchanges for a second day yesterday as the ruble denominated Micex fell by 10% in less than an hour, despite the CB injecting $20bn into the money marketsand the Finance ministry offering $44bn to fund the country's three top banks. KIT Finance, a brokerage, went the way of the Lehman and banks are now no longer lending to one another.  What a familiar sounding mess. 

This is serious on a number of levels though. It has become common to benchmark current situation against the 1930s depression. Everything is the worst, the toughest, the most serious  ... fill in the blank ... since the 1930s. And its true that there were many similarities between what's happened now and what happened then - the availability of cheap credit, the dangerous dependence on that credit to fund the purchase of consumer goods, stocks and fixed investment ... but there are many differences too. 

Firstly, the policy response was different. The Fed believed that allowing bankrupties was the right economically and even morally as it had been warning on the dangers of reckless lending in the preceding years. As the banking system was engulfed in panic and the money supply contracted by one third the Fed sat idly by. Milton Friedman believed that this alone was the difference between what should have been an ordinary recession and the depression which ensued. The rest of the US government was similarly inactive, failing to respond with any sort of fiscal stimulus until Roosevelt's new deal in 1933. Indeed, in the meantime, the government enacted the Smoot-Hawley Act which put up trade barriers and set off a chain reaction of similar responses around the world causing a collapse in world trade. 

Compare that to the central bank liquidity provision, the monetary and the fiscal stimulus we've already seen so far and the current downturn shouldn't be anywhere near what was seen in the 30s. There is no legislating for the utter stupidity of politicians of course, and there are increasingly autarkic noises emanating from the US (autarky as a policy of economic independence and non-trade was born in the 1930s incidentally) but with such a strong trading ethos throughout Europe and Asia it is difficult to imagine the world lurching back into the isolationism of the early 1930s.   

But there is one more aspect to the 1930s crash which is less widely discussed - the US was then the world's biggest creditor nation. When its domestic economy hit the skids it pulled that foreign capital home, badly destabilising the countries it had invested in (most notably Weimar Germany). This time round we have seen the opposite. The creditor nations of the world in Asia and the Middle East have stepped up their investment in the US and played a pivotal role in the recapitalisation of the financial system.

Russia hasn't been a big player in that respect, but neither is Russia the only EM to be in meltdown. The Chinese stock mkt is now down 60% from its peak and its real estate market is looking dangerous indeed with home prices as much as 25% lower in major cities and annecdotal evidence of white elephants all over the country. In other words, the collateral backing of China's banks' balance sheets may not be as robust as it appeared during the upturn. Any fix will likely include their massive foreign reserves which would require a repatriation of the capital currently invested in the US. You could come to a similar conclusion looking at the Gulf states, where authorities appear to be trying their best to prop up domestic share markets while the suddenly softer oil price is reducing inflows of dollars by the day ...

Yesterday the US treasury announced it would give the Fed another $100bn to restore its balance sheet following the AIG loan. Where does the Fed get the money for all those treasuries? The printing press. The ultimate solution to this mess will be the monetisation of dodgy collateral, which may or may not lead to another sort of mess further down the line. Interestingly, gold started its staggering 10% intraday rise almost immediately following that announcement breaking its hitherto tight correlation with the dollar. The dollar this morning though, is weak ...

A study by National Bank Financial says an oil sands mine, including upgrader needs a price of $85 to be economic. Meanwhile, the financial bust is going to make it harder for firms to raise the $179bn the industry expects to need for investment over the next ten years. That's worth bearing in mind as commodity prices sink. The EIA estimated that in the next 25 years the world would need to invest $30tr to satisfy its energy needs. Estimates of the required infrastructure in clean water provision over the same period take that number up to $40tr, or $1.6tr per year. That's more than the annual run rate of the current global financial crisis, for twenty five years ... 

The Fed branch out ... GS made up numbers beat expected ones ... spare some change for an ex-oligarch ... Asian reaction to AIG muted

Wild and hitherto unimaginable events are now happening daily ... overnight AIG was bailed out by the US banking regulator, the Federal Reserve, after what appears to have been a couple of days squabbling between the private sector and the Treasury over just who's responsibility AIG was. What had been sold as a liquidity issue didn't convince the likes of Goldman Sachs, JPM, Allianz JC Flowers who had been party to the negotiations. So it was decided that although the Fed had no real insurance expertise they were better pladed than the Treasury to lend the money. Afterall, they're the ones with the printing presses. 

To be fair, if AIG is merely illiquid as opposed to insolvent, the Fed is doing what it's supposed to as a lender of last resort. The $85bn 24m facility is at a distressed 3m LIBOR + 850bp in return for the option to take a 79.9% stake in the company. The board remain but senior management are replaced and will be charged with selling off assets to repay the loan. Amid all the hooting about tax payers money being used to bail out the Maserati-driving AIG guys that's likely to follow, the tax payer could end up making a decent return on the loan ... if AIG is solvent ...  but what if it's not? The private sector's involvement apparently stalled because the parties couldn't agree on the value of the collateral suggesting it was more than just a liqiuidity issue ...

But who cares - cue the rally!! ... sort of ... Asian markets rose sharply at the open, as the dollar weakened, only to drift back. As I write, they are now largely in negative territory, as the dollar is where it started ... I'd expect this episode to mark a near term bottom in the equity markets, but credit markets have been far better predictors of the future than  their equity cousins throughout this whole crisis and they're still frozen. Maybe the markets have been so utterly spooked by the last few weeks it's going to take a little longer for people to feel safe going back in. Maybe they're wondering how many of their counterparties will be around this time next week ... 

...  speaking of which ... WaMu was downgraded to junk status yesterday too. GS were rumoured to be looking at them for their deposits but that was subsequently denied. Meanwhile, Those Who Walk On Water announced their earnings yesterday and - who'd a thunk it - managed to BEAT net income estimates. I sure am relieved they have all those clever guys working there ... net income was down 70%, trading revenue was down 67%, advisory was down 56%  and Investment Banking was down 40% but they still made money and what's more, more money than all those clever analysts expected. One slight problem - there was no cash flow statement ... still - great numbers eh?

Maybe having branched out into insurance the Fed didn't have time to think through the demand implications of the removal of half of the financial system in the space of a couple of weeks. They kept rates unchanged at 2%, arguing that it is already pumping as much liquidity into the banking system as it can. Maybe, but all the interest rates I look at are higher than they were a few months ago, or even last year and only rate cuts would get them down. But they're scared of zero aren't they? I'd be scared of a heart transplant, but if it was the only think that might save me ...

Barclays look as though they've bought Lehman's US assets for $1.7bn . Apparently some of the LEH guys were complaining that this was a terrible option because the cultures were so different, Barclays being an English bank! Amazing. Surely there's more of a culture overlap for those guys with Barclays than there is at the local dole office?? 

HBOS fell 40% yesterday too, while UBS was down 20% ... I'm becoming numb to these big numbers, but the crisis has been a bit US centric so far. Isn't it about time some non-US banks went down?

 ... and as if this wasn't enough excitement for one day, the Russian market yesterday fell a mind-bending 17% ... and that came after a 50% fall in three months leaving the RTS down 58% from its May high. Now that's what I call a crash ... none of this 4% in day, 20% from the highs amature stuff we've been fretting about ... falling oil prices were cited as the cause but the FT reported yesterday that there are "few oligarchs who do not have $500m to $1bn in loans backed by shares." Those loans came from the banks, but the banking system relies on the wholesale market for 75% of its funding and that market is now closed. While Russian Standard banks struggles to raise a relatively paltry $200m from the market, Standard and Poors estimate that $45bn of loans need to be financed before the end of the year. But no one knows how many loans are collateralised by shares! Estimates range from $40bn to $140bn. Oleg Deripaska and Vladimir Potanin, the two guys fighting for control over Norilsk have a combined $4bn in margin loans outstanding ...

Medvedev said in yesterday's FT before the 17% decline:

"Despite all the global economic problems there are today, the situation in our economy is on the whole completely stable. We definitely have no crisis or pre-crisis situation.”

Does this now qualify? The Russians' sovereign wealth fund has $570bn. Wonder how much will be left after they've bailed out the banks so they can bail out the billionaires so they can bail out the Premiership and the high-end London housing market? More interestingly, Putin has the oligarchs right where he wants them ... what pound of flesh does he extract in return? 

The Minerals Management Service said yesterday that while guys like Transocean and BP go looking for their lost rigs, 97% of oil production and 84% of nat-gas output in the GoM (worth about 26% of US oil production) was idled after Ike. Oil prices rebounded last night on the AIG deal (??) but Libya and Iran have both said they have no plans yet to call an emergency OPEC meeting.

Monsanto said it's full fiscal year profit likely rose more than it had earlier forecast, with ongoing profit running at $3.58-$3.60 compared to $3.37 previously. Can farmers afford these record GM prices, or record potash prices, or record ammonia prices? I'd have thought not, which will surely lower yields over the next few years until more supply can come on stream ... Dell also warned that it was now seeing a widespread slowdown in its business. Not to worry though, HP said the opposite. Cue Nasdaq rally.


Tuesday, 16 September 2008

China cuts but Asian stocks still down 5% ... AIG downgraded ... Iran inches closer to nuclear ... sugar fundamentals looking good

The world has gone ex another inflation fighting central bank after China cut rates by 27bp to 7.20% and also lowered reserve requirements yesterday. The Australians have already cut and everyone else will soon follow as the cycliacal peak in inflation has clearly been seen. As recently as early August, Bernanke suggested the Fed's next move would be up not down. In 2006 the same man - who spends his entire working life observing and analysing the health of the US economy - said under oath that there was no problem in the US housing market. 

AIG were downgraded overnight and this morning their CDSs imply about a 60% chance of bankruptcy. The FT reports they needed to take a $20bn hit on their bond insurance exposure, while a downgrade requires them to post  another $20bn in collatral. But its getting out of control. Yesterday they wanted a $40bn bridging loand from the Fed, presumably adding up those two numbers, but were allowed only to bend the rules so as to give themselves a $20bn bridging loan using otherwise ringfenced holding company assets as collateral. Today, in a Zimbabwesque inflationary leap, they need $75bn.

It seems as though Goldmans and JPM are setting up to lend them that $75bn. Not that either of those banks have anything like that sort of money to lend. But they do have access to the Fed. In March the Fed used JPM as its vehicle to bail out Bear, which at the time as an investment bank had no access to the Fed's lending. It feels like JPM and GS will be used similarly here with AIG.

Will they cut today? I had doubted it. The liquidity response to the panic in the stock market has been comprehensive with the Fed now taking eqities as eligible collateral (wonder if that includes LEH and AIG?) ... more likely was an admission that they're now thinking about it. But BB has shown himself easily paniced by stock market declines so a cut wouldn't surprise me ...in fact, the Fed Fund futures are now pricing in action with greater than 50% probablility from virtually zero a week ago ... the Chinese monetary response hasn't done much in Asia this morning though, where indices are down roughly 5% following on from the US last night. Chinese property prices also rose by 5.3% YoY in August, the lowest gain in 18months.  

As spectacular as the stock drop is that of oil, which is trading down 4% to below $92 this morning. MEND attacked a flow station in a third day of attacks and claim that Alakiri flow has been completely destroyed after what sounds pretty much like all out war, with the military launching air and marine offensives against MEND positions. Shell already announced force majeur on Bonny light deliveries in July and have now extended that. 

Meanwhile, the IAEA said yesterday that Iran had produced 480kg of low enriched uranium and were consistently refusing to answer questions concerning allegations of nuclear weapon making activity. What are the Iranians playing at? Who knows. It seems as though the mullahs are playing a game of brinkmanship with Amadinejad as their pawn-cum-rotweiller. The economy would certainly benefit enormously from a lifting of the sanctions the West is talking about and one would expect that to be the end game. But the Iranians seem to want more than what's on offer.

Rationally, war is in no one's interest. The biggest weapon the Iranian's have (until, crucially, they get nuclear weapons) is to block the Straits of Hormuz.  But that's not actually especially useful as a long term strategy. By preventing the export of their own oil it would harm themselves as much as anyone else. Moreover, their own feeble navy consisting of a couple of dingies and a rowing boat couldn't hope to last more than a few days against the might of the US navy, destroyers and aircraft carriers and all in such an event. And such action would have widespread international support to the extent it lowered world oil prices. And in any battle for public support the Iranian's could only use such a tactic credibly if they could claim to be using it in self-defence defence. That means they need some sort of provocation and that's what the nuclear antagonism is all about. 

The Israelis cannot tolerate a nuclear Iran. They view it as an existential threat (Amadinejad has openly called for Israel to be wiped off the map) and have threatened to take out any Iranian facilites in the same way they did with those in Osirak in Iraq in the early 1980s, and in Syria last year. But an Iranian operation, being much further away and with targets spread out over the country, would be much more complex than either of those operations. It would require Iraqi (US?) permission to use airspace and/or US aircraft carriers. But the US don't want another foreign adventure and would be unlikely to sanction an Israeli attack unless there was no other option. The Israeli noises so far, that they are about to bomb Iran and have conducted training exercises, have largely been bluffs (you don't telegraph to your opponent what your next move is going to be).  But that's not to say they have to be remain bluffs.

So where does that leave us? A nuclear Iran is such a game changer in Iran's favour that they want far more compensation than what's on offer for forgoing it. More posturing by both sidesis therefore likely until some sort of diplomatic solution is reached. Losing Russia over Georgia has probably upped the price the West will now have to pay. But this is a dangerous game indeed because there are euphemistic "hawks" on all sides - Iranian, Israeli and US - who want conflict.

The grain markets are also being swamped by the panic in stocks right now and the associated strength in the dollar, but the Australians said this morning that they expected to haverst 5% less wheat than they'd forecast because of dry weather. That puts the current forecast at 22.5m tons, still materially higher than last year's measly 13m tonnes ... but we're still early in the season down there ... 

... meanwhile, the fundamentals in the sugar market are looking better than they have done in a while with various factors coming into play. As sugar prices have been flat comparered to those of othe crops the Indians have switched production leading to an output drop of 16% according to the ISO. This would lead to a drop in exports of 86%, basically removing India from the export market. Meanwhile in Europe, the WTo ruling on EU dumping of excess sugar supply on world export markets comes into effect on Oct 1st. This outrageous and pernicious EU legislation currently subsidised EU farmers in the production of sugar, causing them to over produce for their domestic market, but allows them to dump that excess production on world markets. That game is now up and there will be a consequent decline in world sugar supplies to the tune of 14m tonnes according to  F.O. Licht in Germany. Allowing ethanol importation from Brazil into the US is increasingly gaining traction with McCain on record as saying he would remove the current prohibitive tarrif which corn based ethanol relies on to compete. Any move in that direction would see a huge diversion of the Brazilian crop towards ethanol and away from sugar ... interesting ... need to check on the inventory position before I get frothily bullish
 

Monday, 15 September 2008

LEH no more ... MER no more ... AIG no more? ... what's the marginal cost of oil? ...Chinese copper stocks fall

Its the markets' turn to blink this morning. This will do down as a defining weekend on Wall St history with Lehman being allowed to fail and ML being taken out by BoA. LEH being allowed to go to the wall has spoooked markets (SPX futures off 3.5% this morning) but there can only be one conclusion: the Fed and the Treasury believe LEH are neither too big nor too entwined to fail. Barclays seem to have been pushing for a deal which would have protected them from lossed caused by the toxic mortgage book, as JPM were when they took out Bear. But neither the Fed nor the Treasury went for it. 

We'll know very shortly if this was the correct decision. Futures, Dollar and most Asian stock markets weak. Europe will open down more since it rallied heavily on Friday in anticipation of a deal. The Fed have braced themselved for this storm by loosened the criteria on the eligible collateral for lending to include equities and all investment grade debt instruments.

Jim Rogers investor, author and world citizen said a few days ago:

"Bernanke is a very-narrow-gauged guy.  He’s spent his whole intellectual career studying the printing of money and we have now given him the keys to the printing presses. All he knows how to do is run them. Bernanke was [on the record as saying] that there is no problem with housing in America.  There’s no problem in housing finance.  I mean this was like in 2006 or 2005."

That sort of criticism must smart. So as arch-capitalist leaders of the free and democratic world it must be a great relief to be able to talk so tough, and finally be able to take the medicine they've prescribed so often to others in the past, to allow failing institutions to die. It's time for a futile gesture, and LEH is it.

The warning signs were there. "Bank of America said to lead list of potential Lehman buyers" flashed Bloomberg on Friday as the equity mkt rose ... while also "Paulson adamant that no govt money available for LEH" ... there is another conclusion which seems to have slipped off the radar screen in the fixation with the LEH stock price though. Maybe the US govt. didn't want to get involved in any backing LEH because it's keeping its' powder dry for AIG? Which surely is too big and entwined to fail? ... the FT reports this morning that the firm asked the Fed for a $40bn bridging loan to tide it over while it disposed of assets. Failure to do so would trigger a ratings downgrade which exiecs are worried would set off a fatal chain reaction. More on that today I suspect. 

Mer are off the Fed's list of things to worry about thanks to Bank of America who have bid $29 per share, which Mer have agreed to apparently. This is surely a massive relief to stock holders as the MER price resembled  that of LEH several weeks ago ...   

So who else is left? Of the big boys, only those who walk on water and Morgan Stanley ... we've had Bear, LEH and Mer, and we've had the GSE's ... AIG are next on the block and then what? a silver lining of falling interest rates now that inflation has cyclically peaked ... who knows? ... what follows today will likely be the low point of this financial crisis, certainly in terms of the financial panic surrounding it. 

Some of the smart money appears to be turning too. Paulson said last week he was looking at buying opportunities in the financial sector, Jim Rogers has started closing out his financial shorts while Jim Chanos believes the worst is over for the financials. And while a less noteable an investor, Jeremy Grantham is an undisputably brilliant intellect and he too now appears to be turning bullish. He believes large cap US equities will return >5% real return in the next seven years ... sounds like the product of analysis way too clever for me, but he is a very smart and thoughtful guy ... he does have a reputation for being a "perma-bear" butI think that's harsh. During the time he has been constantly bearish, developed market equities have gone nowhere ... but most of the talking heads think anyone to the bearish side of Jim Cramer is a "perma bear" ... 

Too late for Bill Miller though, who successfully masqueraded as a sagacious value investor, outperforming the SPX consistently for fifteen years or so. That cumulative outperformance has now been completely unwound now though by his bet on financials in general and the GSEs in particular, where his fund was the second biggest holder. His bitter take on the GSE bailout?

"Most troubling to the market is having private companies seized when they're in compliance with all published capital requirements."

He must be looking at a different market from me ...   

... nothing else seems newsworthy after this, but in pondering the marginal cost of oil, which I thought about $75, Total's chief exec's comments are interesting.  He said in Friday's FT that at prices below $100 planned projects would no longer be profitable.  http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/dc3b9c66-8053-11dd-99a9-000077b07658.html
Oil prices are off a couple of percent this morning, below that $100 level, as hurricane Ike failed to materiallt damage the refining infrastructure in Texas and the EIA released around 300k barrels from the SPR. 

And despite the Chinese property meltdown MS are talking about, Shanghai copper stocks fell to their lowest since January 2003 according to the Shanghai futures exchange. Seperately, metal production data showed a decline in Chinese copper output, while BHP's Kloppers said last week that although demand was weakening, so to was supply as existing mines hit lower grade ores. Escondida, which represents 10% of world output was expected to see a 15% decline. 

Friday, 12 September 2008

Credit markets sieze up ... who's the next casualty? ... when to buy Russia? ...Chavez expels US ambassador

Yesterday wasn't a very fun day as the credit markets appeared to completly sieze up. Reportedly, there were only cash sellers yesterday with no bids at all, one broker saying it was as dry as he'dever seen it, including in the run up to the Bear bankruptcy. Moreover, the iTraxx indices don't hint at the stress under the hood because almost no one is trading CDSs right now because of the huge up front payments now required for the index constituents. Everyone knows there is another casualty - Lehman today, who the hell know who tomorrow? - and feels it's only a matter of time before that casualt starts dumping its market making inventory on the market. It felt like something very bad was about to happen all day, although it didn't ... in fact it turned into a modest rally which has carried through into Asia this morning ... 

No doubt the fastest retail sales growth since 1999 in China this morning helped. Might the consumer now "decouple" from the the slowing export driven sector of the economy? Well, if "decouple" is the latest euphemism for "lag" then yes, it probably will. Property prices are now falling now in major cities (e.g. Shanghai down 25%) making a meltdown look increasingly in the cards according to Morgan Stanley. So maybe we should temper our relief. Anhu Conch Cement - China's biggest construction materials maker - fell 10% this morning on just such concern. 

In recent months the authorities raised downpayment requirement for potential purchasers, and reserve requirements at banks ... look for those to be reversed in coming months. Can you refinlate bubbles once they've burst though? No you can't. But maybe it wasn't a bubble - maybe it was a miracle? I guess we'll just have to wait ... also out this morning was industrial production growth which was reported as the softests it's been in six years ...

Dick Fuld has brought Lehman back from the brink on four seperate occassions in recent times. On Wednesday's conference call he said “We’ve been through adversity before, and we always come out a lot stronger.” So much stronger that they continue getting into these ridiculous near-death experiences every time there's a downturn ... looks like they've finally managed to kill themselves this time though. The stock was down about 40% yesterday and is now trading around its 1994 IPO price! One of the few guys who's done well out of LEH is Mr. Dick Fuld himself, who was paid $40m last year. I'd have blown LEH up for half that ... 

Things are looking very ugly now. Merrill looks like the next target, trading below $20 (from $80 last year and $100 eighteen months ago) as does AIG (also trading well below $20). When the tech bubble burst earlier in the decade most of its darlings either went bankrupt or fell by the wayside. The strong, the ones still standing prospered when the weak had been eliminated. I wonder who amongst AIG, Merrills and Goldman will be World Com, who will be Amazon and who will be Google?    

The Russian index was down another 4.1% after a late swoon yesterday. It had actually been trading in slightly positive territory most of the day ... so how bad can it get? Well let's see ... the banking system relies on the capital markets for 75% of its funding; capital is fleeing the country by around $1bn a day; the banking system has leant heavily to oligarchs who've levered up holdings in Russian stocks; those stocks are now cratering because the "industrialists" who levered into them are now forced sellers of them; power, not the rule of law, holds sway; and that power is concentrated in this man's hands:

However, there is still $1bn coming into the country every day from the oil and gas revenues, and despite having spent $20bn defending the rouble in the past two weeks, reserves stand at $570bn, the third largest in the world. This is the key chapter missing from the usual emerging market blow up story. The entire market cap of the Russian equity market is around $500bn, so they probably have enough ammo to weather the storm (although I don't know what foreign holdings of domestic bonds are ... trying to find that out). 

Meanwhile, the CB is also providing as much liquidity as it physically can to the banking system. This isn't having an obvious effect right now since interbank rates continue to spike. Moreover, transferring dodgy collateral from the banking system's balance sheet to the central bank's rarely ends in anything but tears. But that's a problem for tomorrow. Everything has a price and its beginning to feel like it's time to buy Russia. It has the potential to get uglier first, as these things always do, but if there's one thing I know about emerging market investing its that these sorts of collapses are as inevitable as their timing is completely unpredictable. The only way to make decent money as an investor is to hold your nose and buy when things look ugliest ... difficult to do as a short term trader so we have to wait for the trigger ... just not sure what that might be yet ... 

Maybe it will be a turn in commodities? The historical volatility of of the CRB hit a thirty year high this week according to Bloomberg, although its not clear to me why an indicator which works well for equities should work for commodities, which have very different statistical properties ... oil is stronger this morning though, as are the other commodities, as Ike heads towards Texas and Venezuela expels its US ambassador while threatening to stop supplying the US market ... Ken Livingston's mate Hugo Chavez, eh?